Guidance

Producing post-implementation reviews: best practice

How to carry out the analysis for a post implementation review (PIR).

• From: Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade and Department for Business and Trade
• Published: 20 May 2016
• Last updated: 10 May 2024
  Show all updates

  1. 10 May 2024

     Best practice revised to reflect consequential changes following the introduction of the new Better Regulation Framework and the updated guidance on statutory review requirements. This includes the need to consider options assessments under the pre-implementation stage of the new framework and when a post implementation review should be scrutinised by the Regulatory Policy Committee under the post-implementation stage of the new framework. As per the updated guidance on statutory review requirements, the guidance reflects that for novel regulatory provisions, if the regulatory provision has an impact below +/- £10 million EANDCB (Equivalent Annual Net Direct Cost to Business) then this should be a strong indication that a statutory review provision may not be appropriate. The revised guidance also now provides an overview of which post implementation reviews are in scope of the framework and a section on post implementation review bundling.

  2. 6 August 2021

     New guidance on international requirements following the most recent Free Trade Agreements that the UK has signed with other nations. Guidance updated on the requirements for producing PIRs for retained/amended EU legislation, and the process for publishing PIRs.

  3. 22 January 2021

     slight tweak to the PIR revising the question on EU measures

  4. 19 July 2018

     Added best practice guidance for officials.

  5. 20 May 2016

     First published.

Documents

Producing post-implementation reviews: principles of best practice

HTML

Post implementation review (PIR) template

MS Word Document, 34.2 KB

This file may not be suitable for users of assistive technology.

Request an accessible format

If you use assistive technology (such as a screen reader) and need a version of this document in a more accessible format, please email digital@businessandtrade.gov.uk. Please tell us what format you need. It will help us if you say what assistive technology you use.

Details

Guidance and template for officials carrying out analysis to support the recommendations of post implementation reviews (PIR) of legislation.

The template provides suggested headings for the findings of a PIR and can be used for both statutory and non-statutory reviews. The use of the template is not mandatory, but is recommended.

Please refer to the guidance on statutory review requirements when deciding whether a PIR is appropriate.